Two main movements composed Thai
Buddhism :
|
Since a few decades, in fact since the beginning
of real economic development in Thailand, Buddhism is facing problems.
- First problem is the decrease of monks. Of course there is still
a lot of monks in Thailand, about 200 000 but the number is declining
(same as in Europe where the number of priests is also declining). One of
the major problem is to find new monks. Now with the growing of the
consumption society, less young people are becoming monks. Before for most
people, becoming a monk was a choice of life. Now some people become monks
not by religious choice but only to escape their own life. Becoming a monk
brings high status and for some people it is the only way to reach higher
rank in society.
- Second problem is that people go less often in temples,
especially in big cities. And of course donations to temples are
declining. Before Thai people went to temples at least for every "wan
phra" (once a week), now most people only go for major feasts.
Upcountry where life is not so stressed, more people still go to temple.
- Third problem is due to monks forgetting Dhamma rules. For
example in 1998 an abbot did build a Buddha
statue with a position different from the official positions recommended
by the Sangha. Then he refused to remove it because more faithful
visited the temple and donated more money. He even sold holy water. Is
that business or Buddhism ? It is very far from the Lord Buddha's original
teachings. The potential danger for Thai Buddhism is often inside and not
outside.
- Fourth problem is contest inside Buddhism. During the 20th
century Thai Sangha has confronted with other Buddhist movements:
- * The Suan Mokh School of the late reformist monk Buddhadasa
Bhikkhu, for example, stresses mindfulness
"here-and-now" and rationalism in core Buddhist teachings as
opposed to animist believes often found in popular Buddhism.
- * The Forest Monks school, stresses a
reclusive, meditative life.
- * The cult-like Huppa Sawan focuses on
mysticism.
- * The fundamentalist Santi Asoke
emphasizes self-sufficiency and anti-consumerism.
- * Dhammakaya movement incorporates
consumer values with popular Buddhism. Dhammakaya movement main temple
is located at Pathum Pani. In 1999 it
has been accused to act like a sect, to have distorted and to have
commercialised Buddhism. Still the Sangha council has not taken a
clear position and Police has started to investigate into Phra
Dhammachayo (leader of Dhammakaya movement) assets and soon he will
appear in a trial.
Thai Buddhism has fallen victim to the 1997
crippling economic crisis which is forcing devotees to curb participation in
religious activities. A survey of 1,253 Bangkok residents by the Thai Farmers
Bank research centre found 43.5 percent were cutting back on religious events,
such as temple-going, which normally involve donations of food or money. The
most popular religious activity among respondents was going to the temple
(19.1 percent), followed by the early-morning practice of giving alms to monks
at 18.1 percent and praying (17.1 percent). The average sum of money given to
monks had fallen to 50 bath a time, from between 100 and 200 bath during the
country's boom years. A separate survey of 59 abbots of Buddhist temples found
a quarter had noticed the faithful were donating significantly less money to
their local temples. A third said their temples were having severe financial
problems because of a lack of funds, while 12.7 percent said their temples
were increasingly the target of thieves. Some 16.2 percent said more people
were coming to ask for free meals and 14.5 percent said monks were receiving
fewer alms in their morning rounds.
Articles about monks can be found in Thai
newspapers. Some related bad affairs like raping young girls, seizing fake
money in temples, black magic ritual that caused death to people, seizing
amphetamines pills carried by monks, monks who visited a resort island and
observed beauty contestants in their swimsuits, monk who has got 60 Mercedes
Benz cars and so violates the religion anti-materialist precepts, abbots
having intercourse with women, monks wearing laymen clothes and going to
karaoke, an abbot wearing an army colonel uniform and entertaining women in a
remote house, monks involved in murder.
The moral towards monks is also declining. In 2000
a Thai fashion designer made monk robes used as outfits for female models.
Also an abbot was killed in order to steal the donation money given to the
temple.
More and more people are asking for a global
reform of the Sangha. Major complains are about the Sangha Council
which is composed of 19 monks. Most of them have reached 80 years old. So a
substitution is asked. Sangha Council takes too long time to take decisions,
for example Dhammakaya movement, Phra Yantra. Some critics want to cut the
links with the state's bureaucracy and Monarchy. In fact the Dhammayut
movement is linked with the Monarchy and many monks are accused to look
for honour or gratitude given by the King.
Phra Maha Boonthueng Chutinataro, deputy rector of
Maha Chulalongkorn Rajavithayalai, said "it
was time for the old monks to make way for the younger generation. These monks
are too old and are still in the old world. I see no bright future for
Buddhism if it continues to depend on these old monks. It's time for them to
take a rest and leave the matter to the young-blooded, who are more determined
and truly dedicated to our religion".
Phra Maha Boothueng said the entire system should
be overhauled and made to comply with the country's democratic system and the
new constitution. Sangha organisation is often compared to a big bureaucracy
where promotion through monastic ranks depended on seniority and regulations
laid down by the Sangha Council.